11/21/2002 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

• Dot Schreiner, 14301 Saddle Mountain Drive, commented that she is in agreement with Mr. Alfinito's concern with the size of this home. She added that this would set the stage for future development and would relax the Town's grading policy. Frank Lloyd, 12823 Brendel, stated that the project is visible from his property and Council would be wise to defer any decision to the new Council. Sandra Humphries, 26238 Fremont Road, suggested that living close to the construction site of this home could impact the quality of life of neighbors with the noise created by heavy trucks and the grading. William Downey, 14330 DeBell, stated his concerns that an economic downturn could impact the market for large estate properties. Breene Kerr, 27261 Sherlock, addressed the issue of the substantial grading to be done on this site. He felt additional study would be appropriate for this application. Kerr added that he felt this project was in direct conflict with the Town's grading policy and would set a precedent for future projects. Paul Hogan, attorney representing neighbor Terry Egger, commented that he felt the project dictated further review and requested the application be sent back to the Planning Commission. John Fryer, soils engineer consultant for the applicant, explained to Council that the soils on site • are suitable for fill. He added that all geotechnical and draining issues would be resolved during the grading and building stage. Pong Ng, project architect, 1513 Fairway, Los Altos, briefed the Council on the design aspects of this residence. Noting the detail of the low profile of the home and the fact that 40% of the living space will be contained in the basement, Mr. Ng added that the Town has historically encouraged basements be built to reduce the height and bulk of homes. Sonia Ransom, attorney for the applicants, hoped that Council would focus on the design of the home. Ms. Ransom discussed her letter that had been faxed to Council late 11/21/02 that detailed her reasons for concluding that the Chan residence falls within the categorical exemption for single-family homes under CEQA. Steve Bristow, 11235 Hilltop Drive, suggested Council should change policies instead of making concessions to applicants. Mayor Pro Tem Cheng requested clarification on the question of setting a precedent tonight with a decision to allow the grading for this project. The City Attorney explained that Council had the discretion to approve this item and in the future would have to treat similar applications equally. They could,however,review each project's merit on a case-by-case basis. Councilmember Casey noted that she was in support of this application for the following reasons: • the Town's grading policy is not an ordinance and each situation that is reviewed is unique; the home design is unobtrusive and fits beautifully on the site; the geotechnical and engineering 10 November 21, 2002 Regular City Council Meeting