Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/23/1977PIANNING CCHTISSIIN Town of Ice Altos Hills 26379 Frenont Road Lee Altos Hills, California MR4= OF A REG]IAR MEEIIDIC i4ednesday, February 23, 1977 Reel 56, Side 1, Tr.l, 173 to End; Side 2, Tr. 2, 001 to 1081. chairman called the meeting of the Planning Commission to order at 7:30 P.M. in the Council Chanbers of Town Hall. RXT CALL AND PIEDCE OF ALIEGIANCE: Present: Ccnndssicners Carr, Stewart, young, Schick, and Chairman Hahn Absent: Comiissionets Rydell and Perkins Also present: Town Engineer Alexander Russell, TVim Planner/Engineer John Markl, Secretary Ethel Hopkins. Tbwn Manager Robert Crowe arrived at 7:95 P.M.. CCNSENT CALENDAR: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Commissioner Schick that the Minutes of February 9 be removed from the Consent Calendar and be considered for approval at the meeting of Mardi 9, the reason being that since they were inadvertently am.tted from the Commission packets, the Commissioners needed time to review them. The motion passed by unanimous consent. PUBLIC HEARINGS: 1. LANDS OF MMERIE M. DIC[MISON, File #CU 8016-76, 25720 Altamont Road, Rist r Re tram of Approval on Con U Use Permit for Secondary Dwelling. The Planning Commission received pertinent information on the above use permit in the Than Planner/Engineer's mmorandum dated February 10, 1977. Therefore, discussion began immediately with Commissioners inquiring as to whether the secondary dwelling met Town ordinance requirements for setbacks and whether the use permit for the secondary duelling should be oaubined with the horse stabling operation for the same applicant. Mr. Markl stated that the dwelling did meet Setback requirements, and that while the application was originally forwarded to the Council by the Planning Commission as a eodoined horse stable and secondary dwelling, the Council had requested a separate use permit, but had waived the fees. O mnissioier Schick inquired about adequate parking for both the horse operation and the dwellings on the property. Considerable discussion following among Cao- missicners and staff on whether more parking was needed in addition to the twenty provided for the horse operation and the four parking places provided for the main delling. Chairman Hahn opened the hearing to the public. hblenie M. Dickinson, Applicant, addressed the Commissioners on the subject of the parking. She stated that parking spaces had been increased on the Property, PIANNING CCTRdrSSICN M UITES - February 23, 1977 Page two 4 PU31IC HEARINGS: (continued) 1. LANDS OF MEI= M. DICRI149(k1, File #CU 8016-76: (continued) but that they were not specifically marked out. She stated that there was no problem with the parking places for the dwellings on the property, since there was only ore car for the occupant of the secondary dwellinq, and no great need for two people for parking places for the main dwelling. Thereafter the public hearing was closed, and Commissioner Schick continued the questions m the subject property by asking if the secondary dwelling net all electrical and building code r qu re ents. Mr. Cavae stated that it had to be assumed, since the dwelling had been constructed prior to the existence of the Town, that it was in compliance with the codes in effect at the time. Oxmdssion- er Stewart, however, noted that since codes have changed so rapidly, it could be difficult to grant a use permit to a duelling built even five years ago. Commissioner Carioo noted that if the dwelling came in for alterations, the Town could then require that it be brought up to present code standards. Discussion was concluded, and the following motions made: MY ON SECONDED AND CARRIED: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Q=mssioner Young that the conditional Use Permit for the Secondary Dwelling for Lands of Dickinson, File CU 8016-76 be recon ended for approval. The motion passed with Cannissimers Carim, Stewart and Young voting for the motion, and Cmxmmissim- S ens Schick and Hahn voting against it. (Cmditim 1 from the Staff report was to 6y be included in the reconnendatim for approval.) MYTICN SECMEED AMID PASSED UNPNIM)USLY: It was moved by Ccmmi.ssimer Stewart and seomded by Commissioner Young that a categorical eme ptim be filed for the secondary dwelling for lands of Dickinson, File CU 8016-76. Motion passed unanimously. 2. FRa4NT HILLS (DINFla'(TI1B File #KIT 8017-76, 12889 Viscaino Place, Fequest for Recommn tim of App on Conditional Use Permit for Secondary Duelling. Mr. bblkl noted that he had inspected the promises of the subject property and commented on the impressive view of the creek from the secondary duelling. He noted further that the people notified of the public hearing and listed an the use permit application were all adjoining property owners. There was questioning on whether the setback requirements for the Town could be met by the existing structure since the structure had been constructed before the incorporation of the Town. Commissioner Schick asked if the building were safe for habitation. Commissioner Hahn opened the hearing to the public. No one responded, and the public hearing was closed. MYPICN SECCNEM AND CARRIED: It was moved by Camdssimer Young and seconded by Om missioner Carico to recamend approval of the Conditional Use Permit for the Secondary Dwelling for Fremont Hills Country Club, File #CU 8017-76, with condition one from the staff memorandum dated February 12, 1977. The motion passed with the following Comnissioners voting for approval: Cuudssioners Carico, Stewart, Young, Hahn. Camndssioner Schick voted against the notion. PINVING CMMISSICN MWffES - February 23, 1977 `/ Page three PUBLIC HEARINGS: (continued) 2. Fluor Hrr.TR COUNTRY CLUB, File#CU8017-76: (continued) MOTION SEWNDED AND LNANIM7J[SLY PASSED: It was moved by Comdssioner Stewart and seconded by Commissioner Carioo that a categorical exemption be filed for the Secondary Dwelling for Fremont Hills Country Club, File #CU 8017-76. Motion passed by unanimm+c Oonsent. 3. IANDS OF JOHN M. FUZE, File #CU 8019-77, 27060 Old Tram Road, Request for Recamen tion o Approval on Conditional Use Permit for Seomdary Dwelling. Town Engineer Russell addressed the Commissicners with information on the subject request, noting that it came about because the applicant wishes to ebtain a building permit to remodel the secondary structure. Further information can be obtained by consulting his memorandum to the Commissioners dated February 18, 1977. He noted further that both structures on the ten acre parcel had been constructed prior to the incorporation of the Town. Omudssioner Schick inquired about what portion of Mr. Fowle's property was under the Williamson Act, asking if the use permit would be approved, would the Town be violating the provisions of this Act, Eh'. Russell stated that there were two or three some removed from Williamson Act dedication for the purpose of serving the living quarters on the parcel. 4W Commissioner Schick asked if, with the new construction, would the secondary dwelling camply with codes. Mr. Russell stated that the duelling world be brought up to code requirements, and stated further that both buildings have ample setback areas. Also, there were more than eight parking places on the premises. Oommdssioner Stewart asked about the slope density requirements and if further subdividing could take place. Mr. Russell stated that the property could be subdivided into seven parcels if Mr. Fogle wished to do so. Commissioner Stewart asked for clarification of the code requirements on the amount of square footage allewed for a secondary duelling (page 283, Section 9-5.214- Nnanicipal Code of Los Altos Hills). Chaivman Hahn opened the public hearing; and when no one responded, he closed it. MYITCN SECONDED AND CARRIED: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Caanissioner Young that the Commission reaamwO approval for the Secondary Dwelling for the Lands of Fowle, File #CU 8019-77 with Conditions 1 and 2 of the February 18 staff memorandum or the concurrence with current ordinanoe re- quirements. The motion passed with the concurrence of all Commissioners present. MMICN SEOON M AND UONIMUSLY PASSED: It was moved by Commissioner Carico and seconded by Commissioner Stewart that a categorical exemption be filed for the Secondary D.elling for Lands of Fcwle, File " 8019-77. The notion passed by unanimous consent. 4. IMMS OF RICH, File M 2048-76, Stanbrook Drive, North Cal Staking Services, Inc., Engineers, Request for Recon endation of Approval for Tentative Map. PLAMING COMIISSICN MIN= - February 23, 1977 4W Page four PUBLIC HFARINGS: (continued) 4. LANDS OF RICH, File #IM 2048-76: (continued) M7PICN SES AND CARRIED: It was moved by Cammissiaier Schick and seconded by Cam issia:er Carim to request a continuation to the Mardi 9, 1977 meeting for the Lands of Rich, File #TM 2048-76. The motion passed by unanimous consent. 5. IMM OF A14 -W, File #TM 2050-76, Lasubdivisim of Lot 2 of Tract 4182, (Berry RUI FanW, , Engineer, Request for Recamendation of Approval of Tentative Map. Information m the subject parcel was contained in the Town Planner/Engineer's memorandum dated February 18, 1977, and so discussion began immediately with Ocumiissimer Stewart inquiring about access to Parcel C of the three parcel tract. Mr. Stewart also inquired about what connections to the private mad, Mom Lane, would be planned by the subdividers, remarking, however, that the residents of Moab Lane did not wish to be connected with the subdivision. Mr. Russell noted that a way of retaining the privacy of Moat Lane was to require a spite strip at the end of the road in the name of the Town. Vdhen Ca m ssioner Schick asked what provision was made for access across the parcel for people boarding horses at Rancho de Los Caballos, one of the parcels, Tam Engineer Russell stated that they would have access off Page Mill Road. He noted that in the future, this part of the properly would be blocked off from the remaining parcels intended for subdivision. Chairman Hahn opened the hearing to the public. Mr. Eduard J. Ames, Applicant addressed the Camissioners with reasons for his request tors rvisim. Parcel A would be a horse ranch which would be sold. Parcel S is intended for subdivision, and Parcel C, held at present for financial and tax reasons, will eventually be used for haresites for himself and Mr. Calleotti. He stated that he had no intention of using Mom Lane for any type of access to his property. Jack Cham, 13822 Page Mill Road stated that he noticed a forty foot wide street p�anma to ii�e e`age 01 the subject property which sewed to suggest a future connection to Moa: Lane. He reiterated that the residents of Moon Lane wanted to keep it a private mad. He also called attention to the cloudy issue of the title to Moon Lane. John Clegg,�En ineer for the Applicant addressed the issue of Moon Lane, saying that the applicant has no mtentrms of getting involved in the problems of Moos Lane, nor do they wish to use the too narrow Moon lane. He said that the mad was placed where it is because if in the future residents of the private road wished to connect to the Ames property it would be available. He suggested that a barricade might be placed across the access to Mom Lane to prevent anyone using it for an access road. `, 'h:ere was discussion among Cam mssioners on. the matter of access between the three parcels, with Commissioner Stewart expressing the need for showing the tentative road connections; between Arastradero and Page Mill Roads. PINNING CCMUSSICN M[NUPAS - February 23, 1977 40 Page five P=C BEARINGS: (continued) 5. IANDS CF AIMS, File '#TM 2050-76: (continued) John Clegg, Engineer for the Applicant discussed the issue of access to the parcels, notin4 at a l m separating Parcel A from Parcels B and C with cul-de-sac aceessess bo Parcels B and C did away with the undesirable amount of excavation that was undesirable from the Town's viewpoint. He stated further that the access to Page Mill Road would be through steep terrain. Mr. Russell, however, suggested that the Planning Conmissiol Could reserve sale area on Parcel A if the horse operation were found to be unprofitable and a de- cision to subdivide were madesotetime in the future. Fhen Camdssioner Young asked about Pathway Cu ttee recamendations, he was bold that the present map was for the purpose of separating the seventy -me acres into three parcels. The Pathway Committee will have the opportunity to suggest paths when the separated parcels cone in for subdivision. Discussion Continued for sere time betcen the applicant, his engineer, staff and Commissioners on the wisdom of providing mutual accesses across the parcels for the purpose of present and future subdivisions. Discussion before and after a recess which lasted fran 10:05 to 10:20 ended with the following motions being made to accomodate accesses: 4W wTi N swamm AND CARRIED: It was moved by Ca aiissiauer Carico and seconded by C.mnissiouer Stewart to delete Conditions 1 and 2 and to add a fourth edition. The motion passed by unanimous vete. M7PICN SECCT7® AND CARRIED: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Ccuu&ssioner Carico that a Condition 1 should be added which should read as follows: Reserve an easement for access and public utility purposes across Parcel B for the benefit of Parcel C. The motion passed with all Commissioners present voting for it. M ON SEIXRIDID AND CARRIID: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Camuissioner Carico to add the following as Condition 2: Reserve easenents for access and public utility purposes across Parcel A for the benefit of Parcels B and C. All Casmissioners present voted for the motion. MITIUN SECCNDED AND CARRIED: It was moved by Commissioner Stewart and seconded by Commissioner Schick to add the following as Condition 4: An easeumt shall be reserved by final nap for rights of access for Parcel B to Page Mill load across Parcel A and access across Parcel B for Parcel A to Arastradero Road. The nation passed with Commissioners Stewart, Schick and Hahn voting for it and Camiissiouers Carico and Young voting against it. Thereafter, Commissioner Young stated that the phraseology of the motion was not sufficiently clear to provide a legal requi repent, and in this case, legal advice was needed. Commissioner Carieo stated that the Commissioners were requiring something without being fully aware of what they were asking. Mtten Coarmssioter Stewart inquired about any requirement frau the Santa Clara County Water District, he was told that the Town was still planning inprocements PLANNING CC"ffSSICN MINUTES - February 23, 1977 Page six PUBLIC HEARINGS: (continued) 5. LANDS OF ARM, File VIM 2050-76: (continued) in conjunction with the Water District, and was not prepared to ask for rights of easement until the the second conditional use penut on Rancho De Los Caballos is negotiated. RCTIO E SECCNDFZ AND CARRIED: It was moved by Cann sio ner Cari.co and seconded by Camdssioner Hahn to reamend approval of the Lands of Armes, File #TM 2050-76, with conditions as amended by the Plarzdxg* a mlission. The motion passed with all Ornmissioners present voting for it. M7TICN SECQMD AND UNUIDIDUSLY PISSED: It was m d by Conmissimmer Carico and seconded by Cmu&ssioner Hahn to file a negative declaration for the Lands of Armes, File VIM 2050-76. 6. CDOPaw WAY sunDivisicN File i!•II4 2041-76, Page Mill Road and Three Forks Lane, a , g , t for Recomendation of Approval of Resubmitted Tentative Map for Subdivision. Than Engineer Russell reviewed for the Camnlssion pertinent information contained in his memorandum to them of February 19. Thereafter, City Manager Crone mentioned that another item for discussion ewe from the Council level when the application for subdivision was discussed, that item being the question that even though the comber of lots in the subdivision was allowable under slope density requirerants, were there too many lots for the existing topography? Ca ssiouer Carie asked if Mr. Cro a were referring to Lots 1, 2, and 16 and the possibility that they would have to cone in for variances to accomodate certain features on the lots. At 10:42 a recess was called. The meeting resumed at 10:53. Chairman Hahn noted for the record that in addition to the staff report three letters had been received from concerned residents; and Mr. Russell requested further that the record show that letters had been received from Michael Kuranoff, Bonnie M. Davis, M.D., and Wallace Stegner. Cammissioer Young asked that the record also reflect that omnissicners had received,on Veterans Administration Hospital letterhead, a letter from Kenneth L.Davis, M.D. and Borrie M. Davis, M.D. regarding the subject application for subdivision. Mr. Russell enu crated the questions raised by his mmsrorandon in reference to lots being able to accartrodate artenities such as a hone, swimming pool, tennis court, as well as the problems of fault locations and setback areas from them. He stated that the Town Geologist had never raised the question of increasing the setback area from the fault line even when several different proposals had )neem sent to him. Ile noted further that the cross slope calculations were not o far as 3/9177 other areas of the Town were concerned. He reoamended a Type II foundation to C-Ltw, be used to te the slope. He noted that the twenty foot energe,cy fire road wouldWmtter as a road of variable width to ac=m,,dat, the trees. He reommmen- ded the construction of short retaining walls to cut dawn the scarring of the hill - 44W side. Also, he said that he did not remmend that the easement for the fire road be ernambered in the conservation easement. Mr. Russell questioned if the conserva- tion easement were really necessary, but said that if the emergency access were PIMUNG COMUSSIGN MIN[1P85 - February 23, 1977 Page seven PUBLIC BEARINGS: (continued) 6. C0UTM WAY SUBDIVISION, File #nV041-76: (continued) not retained, then the public utility easerent should be retained for the purpose of providing a gravity sewer line that will eventually hook up to the Page Mill Road line. Mr. Russell said that he did not recamend the access easerent frau the Country Way Subdivision to the adjoining* property owned by the Palo Alto School District, saying that you cannot legislate provisions for a third party, and it was unfair to ask this of a subdivider. He ended his presentation by asking Mr. Bahl if he would be auuenable to a tenant restricting tennis courts on Lots 1, 2 and 16 of his subdivision. Commissioner Schick began the discussion by stating that she wished to go on record as questioning if it was the intent of the Torun ordinance to require that every lot in the Tann be able to accamiodate every amenity they desire, since many of the lots presently developed cannot hold a swinming pool, tennis court and corral. She referred to Mr. McReynolds, who came before Council for a variance even though he awned approx tely five acres but could not aceomedate the cited anenities on his property because of the terrain. Commissioner Carico noted that she and Mr. Russell had gone and looked at the subdivision area under consideration, and that she could see that the fire road as recamended by the Camhissioners would create problems if the Cc mission in- sisted it stay as recamended. She reconended deleting Condition 4, to remove the fire road fran the conservation easment and to make it a meandering easement to accomodate the public utilities, sanitary sewers, and e¢ergency access road. She also questioned if the Cc miissian should allow the road to cone out into two blind curves. She recamended cutting into the triangular area on one of the lots so that the road cares in adjacent to Three Forks Lane. Mr. Hahn asked if the request for the fire road was a necessary one or one for the future. Mr. Russell noted that the Fire Departnent's concern was for roads to fight brush fires in the canyon, and Mus. Carico added that there was a need to hate a way of rescuing people who fall off horses while riding in the canyon area. Mr. Russell said that he had requested Mr. Farwell to appear to explain his requests for a fire road, but that he had been told that it was not the policy of the Fire DeparGrent to appear at Planting Commission meetings. (hair man Hahn terminated the discussion by opening the hearing to the public. Fh. DonBahl, Applicant said that the fault people keep referring to is only a fault trace. It not moved since 5,000 B.C., a long time ago. He noted that he had spent an additional $1200.00 in geological fees to trace the fault line that ons between lots 1 and 2. He called attention to the fact that the residential structures would not be placed across the fault trace, noting that if he had not spent the money to find the fault trace the Commission might legitimately require a fifty foot setback fran it. When asked about changing the configuration of the road, he stated that he did not care where Country Way Subdivision road canes into Page Mill Road, but stated that anythingui.h�to Three Forks Lane does not benefit him./u He did not cause the problem. 39/77) PLANNING ODMAESSICN MMS - February 23, 1977 4W Page eight PUBLIC HEARINGS: (continued) 6. Qx]Nfld WAY SUBDIVISION, File VIM 2091-76: (continued) in discussion that followed, Conmissi mer Young noted that Las Altos Hills is not located in the valley and subject to the liquifying mud that other ccumni.ties bordering it are, and that Mr. Bahl had presented a good case for the twenty-five foot setback. Mrs Fiksdal, Pathway Oo mdttee Chairwomen asked what happened to the tunraxdmd on ' ie�r moire access road andwaste they were rejected by Council. She stated that she would be content with a ten foot wide path, but noted that the path she was requesting was one that was much needed as adross-country trail for hikers and horse -back riders. She said she supported the platys that came on the tentative map. Mien asked by Co=.'ssicner Stewart if they did not have a fire road, would a five foot meandering access suffice, Mrs. Fiksdal said that it would be agreeable. She reiterated that this path would link Page Mill Road close to I.S. 280 to the path system that terminated at Duvenek' a ranch at the other end of the Town. Mr. Russell again reiterated that the Cmmissioners should not get an emergency access road in with a conservation easement. These two easements should be com- pletely separate. Wallace Stegner, South Fork Lane objected to Mrs. Medal's request for a path ani stated t�Fiat Mr. FSIs request would scar the hillside and was also un - tar He said that a fire should be fought by other means such as an air- plane irplane rather than through a fire road access. He recommended putting in a minimal path and keeping bikers and horses off the path. Be added also that if he were planning the subdivision, he world have a conservation easement only, without even a path. To Mrs. Schick's questioning if he rejected the fire mad request, he stated emphatically yes, and added that there is another link to the path system, not as direct, but a link that could be used to accomplish Mrs. Fiksdal's aims. Discussion Continued on the sewer eassment with Mr. Russell pointing out that he was thinking of the future. Onn Black Mountain and Edgerton there were no sewers but there will be sewers in the future, and an easement was needed to provide for this. Mr. Russell, after Mr. Young questioned Mr. Stegner on any suggestions he had for improving the Country Way Subdivision mad, stated that Mr. Bahl needn't assure any reponsibility for improving his mad to accomodate Three Forks Lane. There was further discussion on the alternate pathway link that is complete to Edgerton and could connect through the Koo property, and thereafter the public hearing was closed. Discussion untimed on the matter of where and what kind of easements should be required. Mrs. Carico stated, midpoint in the discussion that she wished to go on moord as stating that this is one of the tines when the naps they have been requesting would have been most helpful. She noted she was not sure how necessary a utility easement in this particular location is. Discussion was concluded with ♦ Mr. Russell's pointing out that having a sewer easement would indicate future Jnr planning and negate the need to condemn the land for sewers in the future. huh. Young also pointed out that a cand®ming agency could possibly come in and take twenty-five or thirty feet with no attention paid to the Town+s concerns. PMWING CCbMSSIo9 NMTES - February 23, 1977 Page nine PUBLIC BEARIIIGS: (continued) 6. CXMTY VMY SUBDIVISION, File #TM 2041-76: (continued) Discussion was Concluded with the following motions on the matter of easements: H rIIN SECONDED AND FAILED: It was moved by Commissioner Young and seconded by Casmissioner Schick to delete Conditions 3 and 4 and to substitute therefore the following requirement: A min zum ten foot flexible easeneitalong the easterly boundary line of the tract for public utilities, sanitary sewers, equestrian -pedes- trian use, the westerly boundary line of said easement to coincide with the easterly line of the conservation easerent, and that the easement be laid out with consul- tation with the Town Staff and the developer. The motion failed with Commissioners Schick and Young voting for it and Commissioners Carico and Hahn against. Commission- er Stewart abstained. WrICN SECCNEED AND FAILED: It was moved by Commissioner Carico and seconded by Cmuissicner Stewart to amend condition 3 to include an unimproved pedestrian and equestrian path. Voting for the motion were Commissioners Stewart and Carico; against, Commissioners Schick, Young and Hahn. M ON SECMED AND CAM=: It was moved by Co mmissialer Carico and seconded by commissioner Stewart to delete conditions 3 and 4. The motion passed with Ocamissiosers Carico, Stewart and Hahn voting for it and Commissioners Yong `. and Schick voting against it. MH'ION SEWMED AND CARRIED: It was moved by Commissioner Hahn and seoonded by Commissioner Young that the following be added as Condition 3: A twenty foot (20') easement along time easterly side of the subdivision from the Koo Subdivision, Tract 5762, to Page Mill Road shall be granted by the applicant, and the easement shall be granted for public utilities and sanitary sewers. The motion passed with Commissioners Young, Schick and Hahn voting for it and Camiissioners Carico and Stewart voting against it. Discussion followed thereafter on the matter of realigning Countryway with Mr. Russell advising moving the road to a right angle and letting other residents of Three Forks Lane ocnnect to the new road. He noted that Mr. Bahr has the ease- ment, and that Mr. Bahl does not have the responsibility for connecting to Three Forks Lane. W. Russell noted also that realigning the road also raises the question of deleting one of the lots. The hour being after midnight, it was moved by Commissioner Schick, seconded by commissioner Carico and unanimously passed to continue through the Lands of Bahl and than to adjourn. Mr. Bahl stated that somewhere, sometime, something must be done to Three Forks Lane. He also suggested that it would be better for Contryway and Three Forks Lane to come together at the same point, also noting that there is a left hand stacking curve now. He noted that the road will be wider when inproved and stated %W that the problem is more the downhill traffic rather than the uphill traffic. After Commissioner Stewart expressed concern for rear -ending accidents that could occur in the stacking lane, it was decided to ask Mr. Bahl to return to the next PLMONG CUWSSICN MH uTEs - February 23, 1977 fiW Page ten PUBLIC HEARDMS: (continued) 6. CCUNM NAY SUBDIViSICN, File #4M 2041-76: (continued) Planning Commission meeting because the issue of the road realignment could not be fully resolved at the late hour of one o'clock in the morning. It was moved by Commissioner Carioo and seconded by Commissioner Hahn to agenda Country Way Subdivision as the first item in the schedule of public hearings for the next Planning Cami.ssion meeting. Mr. Bahl stated he agreed with this motion. Commissioners Carico, Stewart, Young and Hahn voted for the motion to continue the subdivision, and Commissioner Schick voted against the motion. It was moved by Commissioner Carico, seconded by Cc nissianer Stewart and unanimously approved to adjourn the meeting at 1:24 A.M. Respectfully submitted, Ebel Hopkins Secretary